So I’m in Publix last night for my weekly grocery shopping when I hear the familiar line, "paper or plastic."
It always amuses me to hear this and watch the face of the checker or bagger asking. They automatically expect to hear plastic. So much so that it always takes them a moment to realize I’ve said "paper please."
Last night was no exception. In fact, they so expect shoppers to say plastic, that the paper bags are hidden behind the plastic bag loader and under the counter. It took a little work for the bagger to bring out the three or so bags needed for my load. And his expression was rather priceless as well. He was quite put out that he had to go digging for the seldom used bags and had no qualms showing it in his demeanor.
Not only that, but he had no idea how to pack groceries into one. He put my gallon of milk on the bottom, packed the bag with several items then topped it off with my loaf of wheat bread.
Milk and bread in the same bag? Never saw that before.
So what’s the deal with the plastic bags anyway? Why do stores seem to push them on us, when everything else in our lives is so focused on "recycling" and taking care of the environment? And why do they even bother to ask the double-P question when they already so assume the consumer will go for the plastic that they’ve placed the paper bags in inconvenient places for their baggers and don’t even train said baggers in how to properly pack a paper bag?
Oh, and I know what you’re asking me in the privacy of your own web-world as well… why in the world to you take bulky hard-to-hold paper bags over the ease of plastic bags with their handy-dandy little handles?
I’ll tell you why. India. China. Ethiopia. Tijuana. Ensenada. That’s why.
One of the longest lasting images I have of these places is the ubiquitous presence of plastic bags, smashed in the gutters, clinging to fences and walls, wafting in the breezes and filling up the trash heaps. These pervasive and familiar contraptions don’t ever seem to die. They live on in countries and regions too poor to afford clean up crews and overflow garbage piles all over the world. I can’t tell you how often I saw these bags flying through the air or clutching to local vegetation as if sucking the life out of it. In Ethiopia it sometimes seemed that the plastic bag was "grown" along side the tumble weeds and tall grasses.
With each new siting I swore I would never use another plastic bag again in my life. But reality is such a different creature than our ideals. Once back in the States (or in European life), however, I eventually found myself clutching my own little life-sucker as I left my local Walgreen’s or Kroger. The pull of ease and convenience was much stronger than my desire to rid the world of the evil plastic bag. That is, until recently.
Something snapped in me a couple of months ago. I don’t know what it was — perhaps I just finally found my own strength of will (and character?). But I came to the firm conclusion that I no longer have to contribute to the world’s supply of un-recycled plastic bag trash. Every time I’d walk out of the store carrying my plastic bag full of goodies my joy was diminished by the images in my mind of that same plastic bag someday littering the African landscape and diminishing the beauty and grandeur by its very existence. It finally got to much for me to bear. And I decided it is time to take a stand. No matter how small or insignificant it may seem to others. I needed to do something. I needed to do something. So I asked for my first paper bags since I was in high school.
I sounded as if I was asking a huge favor from the checker.
"Paper or Plastic, ma’am?" Even the baggers are polite in the South.
"Uh… paper… please?" Did I actually squeak when I said that??
Oh, but I felt so very good when I left with my paper bags full of groceries. I’d just kept four plastic bags out of circulation. Ethiopia would be a little less in danger of being overrun with those evil life-suckers now.
With each trip to the grocery store it got a little easier, and I got a little more confident in my "paper" declaration. Till one day I found myself anticipating the question and stating, "paper bags please," before the checker even had time to ask.
It also helped that I discovered the self-checkout lines. Except for the fact that they make it even more difficult to use paper bags in those lines. Have you ever tried to bag your groceries with paper while keeping them on that little pad so the machine doesn’t loudly proclaim, for all the store to hear, "Please put the item back in the bag," while at the same time not toppling over and crashing to the floor spilling jam and spaghetti sauce all over the you and the three people at the next two stations? It ain’t easy. But I make it work. Because it matters to me.
Eventually I hope to gather some cotton totes to carry into stores with me, but for now, paper is good. it works whether I recycle, or send it to the land fill. At least it will turn back to pulp/dust many decades sooner than plastic will…. do whatever it is that plastic does when it finally fades away… Does it fade away???
I cannot save the world from hate or war. I may not even be able to clean up our planet and rid it of all garbage and air pollutants. But I can do one thing:
I can lessen the world’s trash by a few bags and, hopefully, help keep it a little cleaner for the next generation. My paper bags may cause inconvenience for the checkers and baggers of America. But if I can help keep Ethiopia from being completely overrun by plastic bags, even in a small way, than it’s worth all the rolled eyes and cranky attitudes I get.
Thanks so much for this post. I just got back from Indonesia, and I saw a lot of the same thing. I recycled while I was in England, but living at home with my parents in Alabama, it’s not that easy. You have reminded me that I need to make the effort.
Right on. We use those things for like 6 minutes and they take like a million years to disappear (after winding up in a sea turtle’s stomach).
I wrote about this same thing on one of my sites:
Take the Bag Back.
I don’t know about Publix, but Kroger has recycling bins for plastic bags. I use the U-Scan, stuff as much as I can into as few bags as possible and on my next trip, I put them in the bin.
And at Wild Oats, I take my own bags with me to use.
I reuse my bags. I’m famous at the local Trader Joe’s for this. I have the rattiest bags in the place. Some from Christmas a few years ago… but as long as the handles stay put.
Most of the time I use a backpack. I just load it up at the checkstand and walk home. Although I’m getting very tired of Albertson’s so am thinking of going to the Vons up the street… which would be a long walk.
And I re-use the plastic bags that cereal comes in to hold other stuff. Why use things just once, when they can be used until they’re worn out? Oil won’t be cheap for much longer, and plastic is made from oil. Not to mention the environmental fallout.
Don’t forget that you can always bring bags with you, whether they’re the same plastic or paper ones you got last time or some sturdy canvas jobs — that’s up to you. We keep about 10 canvas bags in our car’s trunk and use the canvas bags whenever we go shopping. We do sometimes forget when we walk to the Kroger three blocks away and the canvas bags are still in the trunk of our car, which is still parked in front of our house… three blocks away. But as others have pointed out, if you take the plastic bags from Kroger, you can bring them back there for them to recycle.
On the other hand, something else to bear in mind about the brown plastic bags Kroger and some other stores use: some sources say that roaches have been known to lay eggs in them, and you may be unwittingly bringing those eggs into your home. Best thing to do? Get rid of them immediately. If you forget to bring your canvas bag to the store and you have to take groceries home in a plastic bag, you should probably just throw the bags out right away unless you can store them outside to take back and recycle the next time you shop.
(Oh, and I recommend washing the canvas bags pretty regularly, too, to keep them clean for the food.)
Thanks everyone for the support and the suggestions. I didn’t even know you could recycle those plastic bags until this morning, when I was looking for pictures of plastic bags. And I didn’t realize I could just take them back to Kroger until one of ya’ll said so. Thanks!!
Cool beans. Time to get rid of the ones I got and get some canvas bags instead.